Home › The Garage › Ideation
Design thinking

Brainstorming & ideation

Most brainstorms fail for the same reason: people judge ideas as they arrive, and the flow dries up. A few simple rules keep the divergent phase open — then a separate step turns the pile into a decision.

By LeanBean · Updated November 2026 · 5 min read
What's in this guide
  1. What ideation is
  2. Rules that make it work
  3. A few methods
  4. Turning ideas into a choice
  5. Common questions
Diverge — generate many ideas Converge — cluster & choose a few
Generate wide with judgement off; then, as a separate step, cluster and choose what to test.

What ideation is

Ideation is the divergent phase of design: deliberately generating a large number of possible ideas before evaluating any of them. Its enemy is premature judgement — the instinct to critique an idea the moment it appears, which teaches everyone to stop offering them. The craft is to keep the generating and the judging strictly apart.

Rules that make it work

A few methods

Beyond open brainstorming, structure helps: brainwriting (everyone writes ideas silently first, which stops loud voices dominating), “How might we…” questions to frame the challenge as an invitation, and worst possible idea to loosen a stuck group by reversing the goal. Each protects quantity and keeps judgement at bay.

Turning ideas into a choice

Generating and choosing are different jobs
A pile of sticky notes is not a decision. Once the divergent phase is done, switch deliberately into converging: cluster similar ideas, then choose with a simple lens — impact against effort, or desirable/feasible/viable. Keeping the two phases apart is what lets a group be both creative and decisive, instead of neither.

Describe a process. Get the whole analysis.

LeanBean turns a plain-language description of any process into a professional map — with Lean waste, SIPOC, design-thinking, AI-readiness and capacity analysis built in, and a Transformation Coach that sequences the fixes. Free to start.

Build your first map free →

The Garage — a community of practice

The Garage is where Lean, process and AI-readiness practitioners learn in the open — short lessons, real examples, and a place to compare notes. Join the community: follow along, try it on your own work, and share what you find.

Common questions

What are the rules of brainstorming?

Defer judgement, go for quantity, build on others’ ideas, welcome wild ideas, and keep to one conversation on topic. The common thread is separating idea generation from evaluation so the flow of ideas doesn’t dry up.

Why do most brainstorms fail?

Because people evaluate ideas as they are offered. Criticism during generation teaches the group to stop contributing, so the session converges on a few safe ideas instead of exploring the space.

What is brainwriting?

A method where everyone writes ideas silently before sharing. It prevents the loudest voices from dominating and tends to produce more ideas than open discussion, especially from quieter team members.

How do you choose between many ideas?

As a separate, convergent step: cluster similar ideas, then score them against a simple lens such as impact versus effort, or desirability, feasibility and viability. Don’t mix choosing into the generating phase.

Related guides: Human-centred design · What is design thinking · Prioritisation techniques