What root cause analysis is
Root cause analysis (RCA) is the practice of finding the underlying cause of a problem rather than its symptoms, so that the fix removes the problem permanently instead of suppressing it. The 5 Whys is one RCA tool; the fishbone diagram is the other one every practitioner should know, and it earns its place whenever a problem has more than one contributing cause.
The fishbone (Ishikawa) diagram
The fishbone diagram — named for its shape, and also called an Ishikawa diagram after Kaoru Ishikawa who popularised it — puts the problem at the "head" and draws "bones" for each category of possible cause. You brainstorm causes onto the relevant bones, then dig into the promising ones (often with the 5 Whys). Its value is breadth: it forces you to consider categories of cause you'd otherwise skip, which stops the team fixating on the first explanation that comes to mind.
The cause categories
Manufacturing traditionally uses the 6 Ms (Machine, Method, Material, Measurement, Man/People, Mother-nature/Environment). For service and office processes, plainer categories work better:
- People — skills, workload, handoffs, unclear ownership.
- Process — missing steps, unclear rules, rework loops.
- Systems — tools that don't talk, manual re-keying, outages.
- Materials / inputs — late, incomplete or wrong inputs.
- Measurement — no data, wrong metric, or nobody watching it.
- Environment — policy, deadlines, physical or organisational context.
How to run one
- Write the problem at the head — specific and agreed.
- Draw the category bones and brainstorm causes onto each, with the people who do the work.
- Dig into the strong candidates with the 5 Whys to reach the root of each branch.
- Verify with evidence — a cause on the diagram is a hypothesis until data confirms it.
- Prioritise the roots that are both high-impact and within your control.
Fishbone vs 5 Whys
| 5 Whys | Fishbone | |
|---|---|---|
| Shape | Linear chain | Branching map |
| Best for | One dominant cause | Several combining causes |
| Strength | Depth | Breadth |
| Often used | Within each fishbone branch | To scope the whole problem first |
Describe a process. Get the whole analysis.
LeanBean turns a plain-language description of any process into a professional map — with Lean waste, SIPOC, design-thinking, AI-readiness and capacity analysis built in, and a Transformation Coach that sequences the fixes. Free to start.
Build your first map free →Keep learning in the Garage
Short, practical lessons on Lean, process mapping and AI-ready operations — the same thinking that powers LeanBean, in two minutes or less. Follow along and build the habit.
Common questions
What is root cause analysis?
The practice of finding the underlying cause of a problem rather than its symptoms, so the fix removes the problem permanently. The two staple tools are the 5 Whys (a linear chain) and the fishbone / Ishikawa diagram (a branching map of causes across categories).
What is a fishbone diagram?
A root-cause tool, also called an Ishikawa diagram, that puts the problem at the 'head' and draws 'bones' for each category of possible cause (People, Process, Systems, Materials, Measurement, Environment). You brainstorm causes onto the bones and dig into the strong ones, often with the 5 Whys.
Fishbone or 5 Whys — which should I use?
Use the 5 Whys when a problem has one dominant cause you can follow in a straight line. Use a fishbone when several causes combine, because it maps them across categories at once. They work together: the fishbone scopes the problem, the 5 Whys digs into each branch.
What are the categories in a fishbone diagram?
Manufacturing uses the 6 Ms (Machine, Method, Material, Measurement, Man, Mother-nature). For service and office work, plainer categories work better: People, Process, Systems, Materials/Inputs, Measurement and Environment.
Related guides: The 5 Whys · The Gemba walk · The 8 wastes (TIMWOODS)